# Nanny share calculator test, run B

Protocol version 2 (2026-11-13). Captured 2026-11-13 with Playwright (Chromium headless shell 153.0.8010.12). All 12 tools were driven through their pages; none was scored from code alone. Per-case evidence: `work/<tool>-<case>.json` + `.html`, screenshots in `screenshots/`, hashes in `manifest.json`. Answers use the protocol wording: yes / no / not shown / not supported. A "no" means the tool uses a different method. It does not mean the tool is wrong.

Conflict of interest: Sharefully publishes one of the tools tested and commissioned this test.

| Tool | Method | T1 | T2 | T3 | T4 | T5 | T6 | T7 | T8 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DaycareCalc | page | not supported | not supported | not supported | not supported | not supported | not supported | no | no |
| ChildCareCostCalc | page | no (total $50,727/yr = solo) | yes ($27,900 & $22,827/yr < $50,727) | yes (27,900+22,827=50,727) | no (premium follows "you") | no (2.75x) | no (total unchanged) | no | yes |
| ChildCareCostFinder | page | yes ($29.68 (default share rate)) | yes ($14.84) | yes (14.84×2=29.68) | yes (identical) | no (even split, $14.84 each) | no ($29.68 unchanged; $9.89 each) | yes | no |
| Nest Payroll | page | yes ($31.20) | yes ($15.60) | yes (624+624=1,248/wk) | yes (54/46 ↔ 46/54) | yes ($744 vs $624/wk) | not supported | yes | yes |
| FullCalculator | page | yes ($1,267/wk) | yes ($15.85 incl. 10%) | yes (C1 only) | not supported | not supported | no ($1,267 unchanged) | yes | yes |
| Sitter Rank | page | yes ($40 (default share rate)) | yes ($22.40 incl. 12%) | yes (896+896=1,792/wk) | yes (identical) | no (even split, $896 each) | no ($40 unchanged) | yes | no |
| CalculatorFoundry | page | yes ($30.00) | yes ($16.32 incl. tax) | yes (C1 only, 31,200×2=62,400) | not supported | not supported | not supported | yes | yes |
| Cubb Nanny | page | not supported | not supported | not shown | not supported | not supported | not supported | no | no |
| BestBabyCalculators | page | not shown | yes ($14.47) | not shown | yes (per-family only) | yes (1.15x) | not supported | no | yes |
| Daycare Cost Guide | page | yes ($28/hr shown) | yes ($27,600/yr wages) | yes (C1 only) | not supported | not supported | no ($55,200 unchanged) | yes | yes |
| Clino (Switzerland, CHF) [added] | page | no (CHF 24 unchanged) | yes (CHF 12/h of care) | yes (20 h + 20 h) | yes | no (CHF 2,452 each) | not supported | yes | yes |
| Fair Share Rate Calculator by Sharefully | page | yes ($32.00) | yes ($16.00) | yes (16+16=32; 20.26+14.74=35) | yes (mirror) | yes (1.37x, both < solo) | yes ($40; $13.33 each) | yes | yes |

Numbers are hourly unless marked. "incl." means the figure includes the tool's default taxes or uplift.

## Possible error, needs hand check
These flags cover only arithmetic that does not add up or a page that contradicts itself. None has been checked by hand in an ordinary browser yet.
- **DaycareCalc**: the daycare-vs-share verdict reads the wrong way round.
  - California, 1 child: daycare is $1,600/mo and the share is $2,541/mo, but the page says "Nanny share saves $941/month".
  - With 2 children: daycare is $3,200/mo and the share is $2,541/mo, but the page says "Daycare saves $659/month".
  - The page's script prints "Daycare saves" when daycare − share > 0.
- **Sitter Rank**: the page says "Your share rate is 1.67x ... That's in the typical 1.4x-1.6x nanny share range." The script shows this sentence for any ratio from 1.3 to 1.7.
- **BestBabyCalculators**: the formula text says the cost is multiplied by "the number of children from your family". With 2 children the result rises only 1.15x ($578.88 → $665.71), because the page HTML gives the "2 children" option the value 1.15.
- **Cubb Nanny** (minor): the worked example says "28 × 40 × 4.3 × 1.16 = $5,585". The product is $5,586.56.

## Uncertain or worth knowing
- **Defaults drive some "yes" answers.** ChildCareCostFinder and Sitter Rank start from a share rate, not from the one-family rate. Their T1/T2 results come from their default share rates ($29.68 and $40.00), not from the $24 entered. The $24 went into their solo-rate field, which is used for comparison only.
- **Cubb Nanny** has only one rate field. Its guide uses that field for the share's combined rate ("For a $28/hr, 40-hour share"). So the $24 one-family rate cannot be entered as defined, and T1/T2 are marked not supported. For the record, entering $24 there shows $2,394 per family per month.
- **ChildCareCostCalc**
  - The "you" family pays its share of children × 1.10. The other family pays the rest of the solo nanny cost. So two identical families pay different amounts ($27,900 vs $22,827/yr), and the result depends on which seat you take.
  - There is no input for the number of families. C3 had to be entered as "other families' children = 2", which is the same entry as C2s.
  - A state is required, with no default. California was chosen; Alabama gave the same share figures.
- **Nest Payroll**: the payroll part ("Calculate both payrolls": taxes, take-home) did not render in the headless browser. A Cloudflare Turnstile challenge was present. Only the live rate-split summary was recorded. The payroll part may work in an ordinary browser.
- **FullCalculator**: "Nanny Total Weekly Pay $1,267" includes the default 10% "Payroll Tax and Benefits". With that set to 0% the page shows $1,152 (`work/fullcalculator-C1-supp-tax0.json`, a supplementary run). It is unclear whether the label means the nanny's pay or the employer's cost.
- **CalculatorFoundry** pre-selected North Carolina on this run but Alaska on an earlier load. The default state seems to depend on location. The state affects the employer taxes only.
- **Daycare Cost Guide** rounds hourly figures to whole dollars: "$28/hr" is $27.60, "$14/hr" is $13.80, and "$9/hr" is $9.20.
- **Clino** is a Swiss tool, found by web search. $24 was entered as CHF 24. Its model is two employers, each paying the nanny's full wage for half the hours, with no share premium. Its first three captures failed because of my selector; the `-r2` files are the valid ones.
- **ChildCareCostFinder supplementary run**: with "By number of children", C2 gives $19.79 vs $9.89/hr, which is exactly twice (`work/childcarecostfinder-C2-supp-bykids.json`).
- **Search for more tools**: DuckDuckGo was rate-limited, so the search used Serper. Pages that were not share calculators were excluded: Care.com, Nanny Lane and Poppins guides, TrustedCare, Nanny Parent Connection (a Seattle solo-pay calculator), and the Beverly guide.
- **Sharefully**: the page results match `sharefully-reference.json` in all four cases.
- `screenshots/v1-exploratory/` holds earlier captures made under protocol v1, before the evidence rules. They are superseded and were not used for the results.
