# Nanny share calculator test: run A

Protocol version 2 (2026-11-13). Captured 2026-11-13T11:42Z to 2026-11-13T11:47Z UTC with chrome-headless-shell (Playwright chromium_headless_shell-1243) 153.0.8010.12. All 11 tools were driven through their real pages (method "page"); none needed reading code for results. Answers: yes / no / not shown / n/s = not supported. A "no" means the tool uses a different method.

| Tool | T1 more for more work | T2 less than alone | T3 adds up | T4 either seat | T5 siblings | T6 third family | T7 share sets rule | T8 starts from nanny rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DaycareCalc | n/s | n/s | n/s | n/s | n/s | n/s | no | no |
| ChildCareCostCalc | no | yes | yes | no | no | no | no | yes |
| ChildCareCostFinder | yes | yes | yes | yes | no | no | yes | no |
| Nest Payroll | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | n/s | yes | yes |
| FullCalculator | yes | yes | yes | n/s | n/s | no | yes | yes |
| Sitter Rank | yes | yes | yes | yes | no | no | yes | no |
| CalculatorFoundry | yes | yes | yes | n/s | n/s | n/s | yes | yes |
| Cubb Nanny | n/s | yes | not shown | n/s | n/s | n/s | no | no |
| BestBabyCalculators | not shown | yes | not shown | n/s | yes | n/s | no | yes |
| Daycare Cost Guide | yes | yes | yes | n/s | n/s | no | yes | yes |
| Fair Share Rate Calculator by Sharefully | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes |

## Key numbers (C1: $24 one-family rate, two families, one child each)

- DaycareCalc: not supported (no rate input)
- ChildCareCostCalc: total nanny cost $50,727/yr (same as solo, incl. taxes); you $27,900/yr, other family $22,827/yr
- ChildCareCostFinder: nanny $29.68/hr (default share-rate input); each family $14.84/hr
- Nest Payroll: nanny $31.20/hr (1.3x); each family $624/wk ($15.60/hr)
- FullCalculator: nanny $1,267/wk incl. 10% uplift; each family $634/wk
- Sitter Rank: share rate $40.00/hr (default slider); each family $896/wk incl. 12% uplift
- CalculatorFoundry: nanny $30.00/hr (25% premium); each family $16.32/hr incl. taxes ($15 wages)
- Cubb Nanny: $2,394 per family per month (the $24 is treated as the share rate)
- BestBabyCalculators: your family $578.88/wk; nanny pay not shown
- Daycare Cost Guide: nanny $28/hr shown ($27.60, 15% premium); each family $14/hr shown ($13.80)
- Fair Share Rate Calculator by Sharefully: nanny $32.00/hr; each family $16.00/hr

## Possible errors, need a hand check in an ordinary browser

- DaycareCalc: Possible self-contradiction, needs hand check: with California, toddler, 40 hrs, 1 child, the page shows "Daycare Center $1,600 per month" and "Nanny Share $2,541 per month (your total)", then "Nanny share saves $941/month" (the share costs $941 more than the daycare figure shown).
- Nest Payroll: Possible inconsistency, needs hand check: in C2 the summary says 'The nanny keeps one rate — $31.20/hr for the share ... works 40 hrs' ($1,248/wk) while the families' parts total $1,368/wk; the page explains the $120 difference as Family A's extra-child amount 'added on top'. I counted it as nanny pay (T3 yes) because the page script sends it as part of Family A's gross wages.
- Sitter Rank: Possible error, needs hand check: C1–C3 page text says "Your share rate is 1.67x the nanny's solo rate of $24.00/hr. That's in the typical 1.4x-1.6x nanny share range." (1.67x is outside 1.4x–1.6x).
- Cubb Nanny: Possible arithmetic slip in the article text (not the estimator), needs hand check: "28 × 40 × 4.3 × 1.16 = $5,585 total / $2,793 per family"; 28 × 40 × 4.3 × 1.16 = $5,586.56 (half = $2,793.28, matching the per-family figure).
- BestBabyCalculators: Possible inconsistency, needs hand check: the page defines children_from_family as "The number of children from your family" in the formula, but 2 children gives $665.71, 1.15 times the 1-child $578.88 (the option's data-amount is 1.15 in the saved HTML), not twice.
- Daycare Cost Guide: Possible arithmetic slip in the article text (not the calculator), needs hand check: "The share creates $39,344 of combined value from thin air: $8,438 to the nanny plus $23,906 in savings split across two families." $8,438 + $23,906 = $32,344, and $23,906 is one family's saving ($56,250 − $32,344).

## Uncertain or worth knowing

- Defaults drive some "yes" answers. ChildCareCostFinder ($29.68) and Sitter Rank ($40.00) take the combined share rate as a separate input. The $24 went into their solo-rate field and the share rate stayed at its default. T1/T2 are "yes" on those defaults. Neither tool derives the share rate from the $24.
- Even split by default. ChildCareCostFinder and Sitter Rank split evenly by default, so T5 is "no" with defaults. ChildCareCostFinder's "By number of children" option gives $19.79 vs $9.89/hr, exactly twice. That run is supplementary, not scored.
- ChildCareCostCalc needs a state and has no default, so I chose California. Its C3 was entered as "you 1 child, other families 2 children", following its own label ("Total children across all other sharing families"). That is the same input as C2s, and the result is the same.
- Nest Payroll's full payroll step ("Calculate both payrolls") sits behind a Cloudflare "Verify you are human" check. I did not try to pass it. The results are the live split summary that the page shows above the button.
- CalculatorFoundry preselected Alaska on load (possibly geolocation). I left it in place. It affects only the employer-tax figures.
- Cubb Nanny has only two inputs ("Hourly rate", "Hours / week"), and its guide uses the rate as the combined share rate. I entered $24 there because it is the only rate field. So T1 is "not supported", not "no".
- BestBabyCalculators shows only "your" family. I ran C2s from the one-child family's seat, which is the same input as C1. I answered T5 "yes" by comparing the two seats ($665.71 vs $578.88).
- FullCalculator T3 and Daycare Cost Guide T3 are "yes" on C1 only, because C2 cannot be entered. FullCalculator's 2 x $634 = $1,268 vs $1,267 total is whole-dollar rounding. FullCalculator's "Nanny Total Weekly Pay" includes its 10% payroll uplift.
- Sitter Rank monthly figures use 4.33 weeks/month while annual figures use 52 weeks, so monthly x 12 is $76 below annual. I treated this as a convention.
- Sharefully: the page results match sharefully-reference.json. C3 parts sum to $39.99 vs $40.00, and the page discloses cent rounding.
- Extra tools: I searched for other free share calculators (Serper web search, several queries; DuckDuckGo was rate-limited). CarePaycheck's "Free Nanny Share Cost Splitter" now says "CarePaycheck has been retired". The other results were articles or payroll tax calculators. TrustedCare's "Nanny share cost calculator" heading has no calculator, The Nanny Tribe is a solo-nanny cost tool with a contact form, and Nanny Parent Connection is a solo pay-rate tool. No tools were added.

## Evidence

- One output file per tool and case: work/<tool>-<case>.json (utc, final url, http_status, browser, inputs, actions, values read back, result text, screenshot, html, first-party scripts). Each case also has page HTML (work/<tool>-<case>.html), first-party scripts (work/scripts/<tool>/) and a screenshot (screenshots/<tool>-<case>.png).
- manifest.json lists the SHA-256 of every file under run-a except itself.
- work/v1/ holds the protocol-v1 captures: the overwritten *-out.json files and their screenshots. They are superseded by the v2 reruns and are kept only for the record.
